Mostly Sourdough

All things sourdough

  • Home
  • About
    • Culinary School Adventures
      • Intro to Baking & Pastry
  • Recipes
    • Breads
    • Breakfast
    • Brownies/Bars
    • Cake
      • Cupcakes
    • Candy
    • Cookies
    • Custards
    • Drinks
    • Ice Cream
    • Muffins
    • Pie
    • Savory Items
    • Scones
    • Sourdough
    • Vegan
  • Contact

Sourdough Tomato Basil Bagels

April 10, 2023 by Sophie 4 Comments

I was on a mission to recreate my favorite bagel from a bagel shop in my hometown (shoutout to Barton’s Bagels in Marin County!), and I think I finally nailed it!

My go-to bagel is always their tomato basil bagel with sun dried tomato cream cheese. I’ve actually never seen another bagel shop that serves something similar. And I rarely get to visit California much these days now that we live in Pittsburgh. So I was in need of my tomato bagel-fix.

I was determined to make a sourdough version of their tomato basil bagel, using my regular Sourdough Bagel recipe as the base. I added jarred tomato sauce and dried basil, swapping out the honey and reducing the salt a bit to account for the seasoning in the sauce.

They turned out exactly how I was hoping they’d taste. Another key to the nostalgic flavors here is using sun-dried tomato cream cheese (you can easily make your own, or a specialty store may have some pre-made).

Sourdough Tomato Basil Bagels

From Mostly Sourdough at https://mostlysourdough.com/2023/04/sourdough-tomato-basil-bagels/

Yield: 12 bagels

Chewy and delicious sourdough bagels flavored with tomato sauce and basil.

You'll Need...

  • Levain:
  • 1 tablespoon sourdough starter
  • 50 grams white bread flour
  • 50 grams whole wheat flour
  • 100 grams water, room temp
  • Dough:
  • 350 grams tomato sauce
  • 100 grams water, room temperature
  • 700 grams white bread flour
  • 15 grams salt
  • 5 grams dried basil
  • For baking & topping:
  • 1/4 cup granulated sugar, for boiling
  • 2 teaspoons baking soda, for boiling
  • Sun dried tomato cream cheese, for serving

Directions

  1. Levain (the night before mixing): Mix together the levain ingredients in a small mixing bowl and cover with a towel. Leave at room temp overnight until active and bubbly.
  2. Dough Mix: The next morning, combine the levain with the remaining dough ingredients and mix until it comes to a shaggy ball. Allow to rest for 30 minutes up to 1 hour. After resting, knead the dough in the bowl or on a work surface until it starts to smooth out (no more than 5 minutes). Transfer to an oiled bowl covered with a towel.
  3. Bulk Fermentation: The bulk ferment for this dough is somewhat flexible, between 3 and 5 hours depending on how active your levain is. You want to give it 3 stretch and folds/turns over 2-3 hours at 30 minute intervals. If the dough is still slow and doesn't look like it has increased much, let it rest for another hour or two to give it a chance to bulk up.
  4. Divide/Shaping: Line 2 baking sheets with parchment, and liberally sprinkle them with corn meal and flour. Transfer the dough to a floured work surface. Divide it into 12 even portions (at about 115 grams each). You can pre-shape the bagels into tight little balls if you are going to poke a hole through them, or leave them as blobs and then roll them out into even logs and attach the ends to make a circle. I prefer the poke. Place each shaped bagel on the baking trays (6 per tray), stretching out the holes a little as you go since they will relax back in a bit.
  5. Overnight Proof: Wrap the baking sheets in plastic wrap, and allow to sit at room temperature for 30 minutes to jump start the proof. Then stick them in the fridge overnight until the next morning.
  6. Final Proof: The next morning, remove the bagels from the fridge and allow to sit at room temp for an hour or so. Preheat the oven to 450 degrees. To a large wide pot, add 1 gallon of water and mix in the sugar and baking soda. Bring to a boil, and then reduce to a consistent simmer. Prepare a wire cooling rack with a dish towel underneath next to the oven so you can drain the bagels as you go. Also line 2 baking sheets with parchment and dust with cornmeal (or if you only have 2 baking sheets, have the tools at the ready so when you remove your proofed bagels to boil them, you can re-prep the pans).
  7. Boil & Bake: Once the oven is preheated you can start boiling. Add 3-4 bagels to the water at a time (depending on how large the pot is), and boil for 30 seconds, flip them and then another 30 seconds. Transfer to the cooling rack to drain before starting the next batch. Put 6 boiled bagels on each baking sheet. Bake for 20-22 minutes until nice and golden.
  8. The bagels can be frozen in a single layer on a baking sheet and then popped into a baggy for saving; just pull them out as you want to eat them. They can be thawed in the microwave for ~30 seconds, or in a few hours at room temp.
Generated with ♥︎ by Matcha Print

I’m so happy with how these came out, and I can’t wait to keep experimenting with more bagel flavors.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

« Sourdough S’mores Cookies
Sourdough Pumpkin Muffins »

Comments

  1. Connie says

    August 18, 2023 at 2:33 am

    Love your recipes!

    Reply
    • Sophie says

      August 19, 2023 at 6:37 pm

      Thanks so much!

      Reply
  2. Cathleen Fitzgerald says

    April 6, 2025 at 8:20 pm

    Love your recipes. Do you atill li e in Pottsburgh? Im.in Dormont

    Reply
    • Sophie says

      May 3, 2025 at 2:14 pm

      Thanks so much! I am not in Pgh anymore. Moved back to the west coast! 🙂

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome to Mostly Sourdough

Hi there! I'm Sophie. In this little nook of the interwebs you will find mostly recipes that incorporate sourdough and sourdough discard, as I am a true baker at heart. … Read More

Connect!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Search the site…

Explore Categories…

Archives

Keep in Touch!

Receive updates via email

Insta Feed

✌🏻 2024. So many fun bakes, can’t wait to k ✌🏻 2024. So many fun bakes, can’t wait to keep on baking away next year. 🥖🥨🥐

Happy New Year! 🍾🎉

#sourdough #sourdoughbaking #bread #happynewyear #yearinreview
Merry Christmas and happy holidays bread friends! Merry Christmas and happy holidays bread friends! 🎄🥖 

Painted this cute little gingerbread house with @portaleopaints. Scored with my @wiremonkeyshop Poco lame, using my @thebreadmat, baked in the @challengerbreadware pan. 🤍

#sourdough #sourdoughbaking #sourdoughscoring #sourdoughbread #christmasbaking
Happy December bread friends! Snow is always on th Happy December bread friends! Snow is always on the brain now that we live in the mountains. ❄️🏔️ Here’s a cute snowflake sourdough design. ❄️

Baked using my fave @wiremonkeyshop Poco lame for scoring, and the the wonderful @thebreadmat in my @challengerbreadware pan. 

Get 10% off The Bread Mat & their proofing baskets using my code “MostlySourdough” & 10% off @wiremonkeyshop using the link in my profile 🌾❄️💙

#sourdough #bread #sourdoughbread #sourdoughscoring #sourdoughbaking #baking #breadbaking #breadmaking #breadscoring #bakingbread #scoringbread #scoringsourdough #breadstagram #homemadebread #breadbaker #artisanbread #realbread #winterbaking
Another Thanksgiving season, another turkey sourdo Another Thanksgiving season, another turkey sourdough loaf! 🦃 These silly shaped loaves always make me giggle. 

As a vegetarian, this is my fave way to celebrate turkey-day, birdless hehe. 🥖

This design was originally inspired by @sourdoughwithsachi, but there’s so many great turkey loaves each year. Baked using the @thebreadmat in the @challengerbreadware pan. 🦃🧡 Get 10% off The Bread Mat & @rosehillsourdough bannetons with my code “MostlySourdough”
•
•
•
#sourdough #sourdoughturkey #turkeyday #turkeybread #veganturkey #thanksgiving #breadislife #sourdoughbread #vegetarianthanksgiving
Happy Halloween! 🎃 Here’s a spooky painted gh Happy Halloween! 🎃 Here’s a spooky painted ghost loaf to celebrate. 👻🖤 I love doing this scalloped ear design with the snipped beads. 🌾

I used @portaleopaints oil based edible paints, my @wiremonkeyshop Poco lame, baked on my @thebreadmat in my @challengerbreadware pan. Entry for #myspookysourdough by @artbreadlove @loaf_fi_bread @petalandproof 🖤

Get 10% off The Bread Mat & their proofing baskets & 10% off @wiremonkeyshop using the links in my profile 🌾

#sourdough #bread #sourdoughbread #sourdoughscoring #sourdoughbaking #halloween #halloweenbaking #ghosts #ghostpainting #fall #fallbaking #breadmaking #breadscoring #bakingbread #scoringbread #scoringsourdough #breadstagram #homemadebread #breadbaker #artisanbread #autumn
Baby baguettes are definitely my favorite thing to Baby baguettes are definitely my favorite thing to bake and eat these days. They’re just so cute and crustyyy. Finally tried out some fun new scoring patterns on these sourdough demi baguettes, and I can’t wait to keep playing around with it. 🌾🥖

These demi baguettes fit perfectly in the @challengerbreadware pan, using the @thebreadmat & scored with my @wiremonkeyshop arc & Poco lames. Get 10% off WireMonkey & TheBreadMat using the code applied links in my prof.

#sourdough #sourdoughbaking #sourdoughbread #baguette

Copyright © 2025 · Foodie Child Theme by Shay Bocks · Built on the Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress